Lenah
Follow us
Justice Hub
  • My Justice
  • News
  • Insights
  • Justice Explained
  • About Us
No Result
View All Result
Justice Hub
  • My Justice
  • News
  • Insights
  • Justice Explained
  • About Us
No Result
View All Result
Justice Hub
No Result
View All Result

Will Bensouda ignore Senate torture report?

December 14, 2014
in News
0
0
Home News
FacebookTwitterLinkedInWhatsappEmail

By Niklas Jakobsson

Torture and human rights abuses. The world of International Justice exploded with reactions and analysis after the US Senate presented its long-awaited torture report. The document vividly described horrific acts of torture and human rights abuses,adding fuel to an already burning fire relating to US violence.

Mainstream media spent most of its time asking questions relating to former Vice President Dick Cheney, to what extent the then President George W Bush knew about the abuses and what the future safety concerns could be. But what about that international institution that was established to try crimes against humanity, genocide, war crimes and a whole bunch of other horrendous crimes? Could International Criminal Court Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda finally get a high-profile case that could make (or break) the ICC?

With the recent failure of the case against Kenyan President Uhuru Kenyatta, many questions have already been raised regarding the ICC’s actual power and influence in prosecuting the crimes it was created to deal with. So if the court can’t deal with the state of Kenya, how will it deal with (arguably) the most powerful country in the world? Mark Kersten – founder of the blog Justice in Conflict – believes that there are two approaches to this argument.

“Here is the argument that the court is in too weak of a position to pursue the prosecution of citizens from great powers. The fear here is that the positive relationship the court worked so hard to earn shouldn’t be sacrificed for a fight that the ICC can’t win. The second viewpoint is that the court is in too weak of a position and thus it must confront abuses from great powers.”

But a possibility to prosecute a possible case based on the report might not even be possible, at least if the arguments of Eugene Kontorovich, law professor at Northwestern University, hold up.

“Gravity represents a more serious and viable obstacle to ICC prosecutions. While the gravity criteria is very fuzzy and unsettled, it has both a qualitative and quantitative dimension. One needs a certain body count. Thus the ICC Prosecutor has dismissed investigations into alleged improper uses of force by both British and Israeli troops on the grounds of insufficient gravity, when the casualties numbered around ten people.

The Senate report finds 39 detainees were subject to harsh treatment from 2002-2008 (and some might be excluded from the ICC’s consideration for temporal jurisdiction reasons). It is not clear if all these crimes occurred in Afghanistan, where territorial jurisdiction exists.”

Another question that might come up is who should be tried for these crimes? President Barrack Obama has already announced immunity for those involved in the program. How will this go down with the Office of the Prosecutor? Putting a face to a case has been the strategy of the ICC since its beginning – whether it is Uhuru Kenyatta, Laurent Gbagbo or Jean-Pierre Bemba. Will the face of an ICC trial be the once mighty Dick Cheney? Some Twitter users believe that Cheney should appear in the docks – no matter the institution.

Finding a responsible party to prosecute will most likely be one of the ICC’s main struggle, if they get to the point of a preliminary investigation.

So…

  • If a case were to get to the court, who do you think should appear in front of the ICC?
  • Is the ICC powerful enough to charge US officials?
  • Will anyone be held accountable for the crimes described in the report?

Lead image: Dr. Meddy is a cartoonist who works for Cartoon Movement.

The Weekly Hubble features the most popular or controversial international justice story of the past week and reactions on social media to the news. 

Tags: human rightsICC (International Criminal Court)Justice Newswar crimes
ShareTweetShareSendSend

Justice Hub

Justice Hub is an online platform connecting conversations about international justice.

Related Posts

ICL Media Review: Russian veterans seek ICC investigation into use of mercenaries in Syria
ICL Media Review

ICL Media Review: Russian veterans seek ICC investigation into use of mercenaries in Syria

by ICL Media Review
November 18, 2019
0
27

In this week's review, news about the ECCC conviction of Chea and Samphan for genocide, the adjournment of Kwoyelo’s trial...

Read more
NPWJ: Trump’s Transgender Military Ban Gets a Boost

NPWJ: Trump’s Transgender Military Ban Gets a Boost

January 24, 2019
43
ICL Media Review: Charles Taylor’s ex-wife pleads not guilty in UK trial on torture in Liberia

ICL Media Review: Charles Taylor’s ex-wife pleads not guilty in UK trial on torture in Liberia

January 24, 2019
39
ICL Media Review: Uganda ordered to compensate former LRA fighter Thomas Kwoyelo

ICL Media Review: Uganda ordered to compensate former LRA fighter Thomas Kwoyelo

January 24, 2019
31
NPWJ: European Parliament to hold hearing on the current human rights and humanitarian situation in Yemen

NPWJ: European Parliament to hold hearing on the current human rights and humanitarian situation in Yemen

January 22, 2019
46

Justice Hub

Justice Hub is an online platform connecting conversations about international justice.

Justice Hub

Justice Hub is an online platform aimed at a worldwide audience of 18-35 year olds, especially in countries where people are looking for sustainable and innovative solutions to problems of justice, peace and security. Justice can feel too abstract, too often owned by experts. We make the conversations lively and accessible.

Follow Us

Quick Links

  • Featured
  • My Justice
  • News
  • Insights
  • Justice Explained
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

 

  HPPJ Forum Login
Creative Commons Licence
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
No Result
View All Result
  • My Justice
  • News
  • Insights
  • Justice Explained
  • About Us

© 2018 Justice Hub

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

*By registering into our website, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Login

Lost password?
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.

REPUBLISHING TERMS

You may republish this article online or in print under our Creative Commons license. You may not edit or shorten the text, you must attribute the article to Aeon and you must include the author’s name in your republication.

If you have any questions, please email nsharafa@gmail.com

License

Creative Commons License AttributionCreative Commons Attribution
Will Bensouda ignore Senate torture report?