Lenah
Follow us
Justice Hub
  • My Justice
  • News
  • Insights
  • Justice Explained
  • About Us
No Result
View All Result
Justice Hub
  • My Justice
  • News
  • Insights
  • Justice Explained
  • About Us
No Result
View All Result
Justice Hub
No Result
View All Result

ICC Prosecution ‘likely’ to look at MH17 downing

September 9, 2015
in Justice Explained|News
0
0
Home Justice Explained|News
FacebookTwitterLinkedInWhatsappEmail

By Niklas Jakobsson

With Ukraine’s latest move of extending additional jurisdiction to the International Criminal Court, there’s a possibility that the Court will look into the downing of Malaysia Airlines flight MH17.

In an email to Justice Hub, the Office of the Prosecutor at the ICC confirmed that the downing of MH17 is likely to be looked at by the OTP, at the early stages of its assessment: “This event occurred during the time frame covered by Ukraine’s latest declaration accepting ICC jurisdiction. It will therefore likely be included in the Office’s preliminary assessment relating to alleged crimes committed in Ukraine”, the email reads.

Carrie Comer, the permanent representative to the ICC for the International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH), welcomes a potential look at the MH17 downing by the prosecution, but believes it shouldn’t overshadow other crimes committed during the conflict.

“The news that the OTP will analyse the downing of flight MH17 will bring the situation in the Ukraine back onto the front page of international news. Nonetheless, an analysis of the attack on MH17 as a possible war crime should not overshadow the numerous accounts of war crimes committed against Ukrainian civilians in Donbass and other areas of eastern Ukraine over the past 18 months of conflict, as well as grave and long-lasting violations in Crimea.”

The MH17 statement from the Prosecution’s office doesn’t come as a surprise to Sergey Vasiliev, postdoctoral researcher at the Department of Criminal Law and Criminology, VU University in Amsterdam.  However, he thinks it’s unlikely the probe will go any further than the preliminary stages.

“It seems logical for the OTP not to exclude the possibility of covering the MH17 incident as part of the PE with the extended timeframe. But I doubt the prospect of it being investigated and charged at the ICC for reasons such as material jurisdiction and admissibility.”

Kevin Jon Heller, professor of criminal law at SOAS, University of London, believes that, although the downing of MH17 could be categorised as a war crime or a crime against humanity, it will not be possible for the Court to bring prosecution.

“Everything we know about the attack indicates that the attackers genuinely believed the airplane was military. Unless the OTP or the multi-national investigation develops evidence to the contrary, it will be impossible to prosecute the attackers for either a war crime or a crime against humanity because they will have a legitimate mistake of fact defence. If they thought they were attacking a military plane, they did not knowingly attack civilians.”

Aaron Matta, senior researcher at The Hague Institute for Global Justice, believes it will be difficult for the Court to bring forward cases for crimes from the extended jurisdiction given by Ukraine.  

“Particularly the MH17, as in order to prove individual criminal liability, they will also have to prove intent.”

Cooperation and pressure from Russia could be also an issue for the Court, as it has previously received criticism for one-sided investigations into situations. The Court also has a long history of lack of cooperation from states, the latest example being South Africa’s refusal to execute the ICC arrest warrant against Sudanese president Omar al-Bashir. In its response to Justice Hub, the OTP highlighted their independent and impartial analysis of alleged crimes.

“As with all preliminary examinations, the Office will conduct an independent and impartial analysis of the alleged crimes committed during this period, in accordance with our mandate under the Rome Statute. “

There’s currently an ongoing multi-national investigation into the downing of MH17, which means that a case could be inadmissable at the Court. Kevin Jon Heller thinks the Netherlands could throw a spanner in the works if the downing of MH17 were to ever move beyond the initial stages at the ICC. 

“The mere fact of an investigation is not enough to make the MH-17 case inadmissible. First, the multi-national investigation would have to focus on the same suspects and the same conduct the OTP is investigating. The conduct is obviously the same, and the suspects would likely be the same, as well. But it’s worth keeping in mind. 

Second, and more importantly, one of the states investigating would have to formally challenge the admissibility of the case. The Netherlands likely would, but it’s still a formal requirement.”

Although MH17 will likely be looked at by the ICC, it seems unlikely that it will ever move beyond the initial stages. However, the court will still have its hands full looking at the annexation of Crimea and deaths caused by fighting in the Donbass region. This will be carried out alongside the already ongoing preliminary examination into the Maidan events that took place in late 2013 and early 2014.

Related article – Courtside Justice: What does Ukraine’s latest ICC move mean? 

Emanuele del Rosso is a cartoonist who works for Justice Hub. 

Tags: ICC (International Criminal Court)Justice NewsMH17Ukraine
ShareTweetShareSendSend

Justice Hub

Justice Hub is an online platform connecting conversations about international justice.

Related Posts

Why is the Libya situation at the International Criminal Court?
Justice Explained|News

Why is the Libya situation at the International Criminal Court?

by Justice Hub
March 14, 2016
0
9

By Emanuele del Rosso Libya was a dictatorship from 1969 until 2011. Protests against the rule of Muammar Gaddafi began in...

Read more
Burundi’s Awkward — and Mostly Pointless — Farewell to the ICC

Prosecuting the Destruction of Shrines at the ICC – A Clash of Civilisations?

March 2, 2016
13
Mixed reactions to the start of the Dominic Ongwen hearing

Mixed reactions to the start of the Dominic Ongwen hearing

January 24, 2016
10
An inside look into how the ICC works

An inside look into how the ICC works

January 19, 2016
9
What is justice? The best of the series “My Justice”

Lino Owor Ogora, an advocate for the victims in northern Uganda

December 8, 2015
31

Justice Hub

Justice Hub is an online platform connecting conversations about international justice.

Justice Hub

Justice Hub is an online platform aimed at a worldwide audience of 18-35 year olds, especially in countries where people are looking for sustainable and innovative solutions to problems of justice, peace and security. Justice can feel too abstract, too often owned by experts. We make the conversations lively and accessible.

Follow Us

Quick Links

  • Featured
  • My Justice
  • News
  • Insights
  • Justice Explained
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

 

  HPPJ Forum Login
Creative Commons Licence
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
No Result
View All Result
  • My Justice
  • News
  • Insights
  • Justice Explained
  • About Us

© 2018 Justice Hub

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

*By registering into our website, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Login

Lost password?
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.

REPUBLISHING TERMS

You may republish this article online or in print under our Creative Commons license. You may not edit or shorten the text, you must attribute the article to Aeon and you must include the author’s name in your republication.

If you have any questions, please email nsharafa@gmail.com

License

Creative Commons License AttributionCreative Commons Attribution
ICC Prosecution ‘likely’ to look at MH17 downing