Lenah
Follow us
Justice Hub
  • My Justice
  • News
  • Insights
  • Justice Explained
  • About Us
No Result
View All Result
Justice Hub
  • My Justice
  • News
  • Insights
  • Justice Explained
  • About Us
No Result
View All Result
Justice Hub
No Result
View All Result

Gravity brings the OTP down to earth

July 19, 2015
in Justice Explained
0
0
Home Justice Explained
FacebookTwitterLinkedInWhatsappEmail

By Niklas Jakobsson

It was the International Criminal Court in a nutshell: last Thursday, Pre-Trial Chamber I decided to hand down its decision on the Mavi Marmara incident – at 17:30 in the afternoon. My frustration over the notoriously poor timing of the ICC was quickly replaced with childish enthusiasm.

The Mavi Marmara has been a rollercoaster ride for the Court and its observers – from the Office of the Prosecutor’s decision to not open an investigation in November to the request for review by the Union of Comoros in January. Although a case on the periphery for many, with its relatively limited number of casualties, the preliminary examination only raised a few eyebrows outside the group of people with a personal or professional interest.

But the decision handed down by the PTC could have huge implications on the future workings of the Court, and even more so on how the OTP conductd its preliminary examinations. The word ‘historic’ might get thrown around a bit too much in these circles – but, for once, it feels justified.

Tweet.

Tweet.

But as much as the decision can be seen as historic, some commentators saw it as controversial and, to some extent, dangerous.

Tweet.

Tweet.

There are several implications to procedures and interpretations of the Rome Statute that will be discussed extensively as a result of this decision. However, another key issue is how it might affect people’s perception of how the Court views Israel. 

Tweet.

Tweet.

The decision by the PTC was not unanimous, but instead by majority. Dissenting Hungarian Judge Peter Kovacs came out swinging, not just against his fellow judges but also about the prosecution’s original findings. Not only did he disagree with the majority that the prosecution should review its original decision, he also argued against the prosecution’s findings that it was reasonable to believe that acts constituting war crimes had been committed by Israeli soldiers during the Mavi Marmara raid.

With more voices being raised about an anti-Israeli bias at the Court, one could argue that Israel seems to have one judge championing their cause at the ICC.

Tweet.

The most important thing to note is what this decision means in practice for the way the Mavi Marmara incident is dealt with. Although the PTC has requested the OTP to review its original decision, it’s still up to the discretion of Fatou Bensouda and Co. to decide whether to initiate an investigation. If she doesn’t? Then that’ll be the end of the Mavi Marmara at the ICC. But the legacy of the procedure and decisions that have taken place until now will be highly debated for years to come.

So…

  • What do you think about the PTC’s decision last week?
  • What implications do you believe it will have on the prosecutor’s future work?
  • How likely do you think it is that the prosecution will open an investigation?

Lead image: Thousands of Turks greet the Mavi Marmara as it arrives back in Turkey (Photo: Stringer/EPA)

The Weekly Hubble features the most popular or controversial international justice story of the past week and reactions on social media to the news. 

Tags: ICC (International Criminal Court)Israeli–Palestinian conflict
ShareTweetShareSendSend

Justice Hub

Justice Hub is an online platform connecting conversations about international justice.

Related Posts

A legal path to justice emerges for Myanmar
Featured

A legal path to justice emerges for Myanmar

by Sean Bain
October 7, 2018
0
59

On September 27 a partial but significant foundation was laid to provide accountability for gross human rights violations in Myanmar,...

Read more
Lawfare: Iran-US nuclear deal row to play out in Hague Courtroom (Part I)

Lawfare: Iran-US nuclear deal row to play out in Hague Courtroom (Part I)

September 26, 2018
56
A trial for history: Thomas Kwoyelo in Uganda

A trial for history: Thomas Kwoyelo in Uganda

September 25, 2018
69
Celebrating women in peacekeeping

Celebrating women in peacekeeping

September 24, 2018
58
Hague court could give Iran a moral victory over the US (Part 3)

Hague court could give Iran a moral victory over the US (Part 3)

September 22, 2018
77

Justice Hub

Justice Hub is an online platform connecting conversations about international justice.

Justice Hub

Justice Hub is an online platform aimed at a worldwide audience of 18-35 year olds, especially in countries where people are looking for sustainable and innovative solutions to problems of justice, peace and security. Justice can feel too abstract, too often owned by experts. We make the conversations lively and accessible.

Follow Us

Quick Links

  • Featured
  • My Justice
  • News
  • Insights
  • Justice Explained
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

 

  HPPJ Forum Login
Creative Commons Licence
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
No Result
View All Result
  • My Justice
  • News
  • Insights
  • Justice Explained
  • About Us

© 2018 Justice Hub

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

*By registering into our website, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Login

Lost password?
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.

REPUBLISHING TERMS

You may republish this article online or in print under our Creative Commons license. You may not edit or shorten the text, you must attribute the article to Aeon and you must include the author’s name in your republication.

If you have any questions, please email nsharafa@gmail.com

License

Creative Commons License AttributionCreative Commons Attribution
Gravity brings the OTP down to earth